Music / opera

Der Prinz von Homburg


Reviews (8)


The guardian

d. 2. July 2020

By

By

Andrew Clements (musikanmelder)

d. 2. July 2020

"Its economy and tautness seem a deliberate contrast to the lushness of the works that preceded it ... [The recording is] by no means ideal - the recording balance is sometimes uneven, and so is the cast, even though Robin Adams is very impressive as the dreamy prince - but the score's dramatic power certainly comes across".


MusicWeb international

2020 August

By

By

Stephen Barber (musikanmelder)

2020 August

"Henze was the leading composer of German opera in the years after the war but the representation of them in recordings has been patchy, though a few can be found on unofficial live opera labels. This version of Der Prinz von Homburg turns out to be the first on CD ... The music is in an eclectic idiom which draws both on German musical traditions, such as Mahler and Berg ... The performance I would describe as workman-like. The cast is largely German, as one would expect, with the exception of the title role, which is taken by Robin Adams ... He makes an eloquent Homburg ... Vera-Lotte Böcker makes an affecting Natalie, and of the other parts I was particularly taken with Moritz Kallenberg's Hohenzollern ... Cornelius Meister conducts with authority and the orchestra plays well".


MusicWeb international

2020 December

By

By

Roy Westbrook

2020 December

"The score is varied and impressive ... Stephan Kimmig's production is less persuasive than the work itself ... There is a certain problematic strangeness in both play and opera, so why not reflect that rather than explain it away? ... The cast serves the work well. Robin Adams as Homburg carries the day, highly committed to his demanding role, rising to every vocal and histrionic challenge. Vera-Lotte Boecker, as Natalie sings a musically wide-ranging part very well and acts convincingly ... The support roles are well taken in an even cast. The Staatsoper Orchestra ... have the most impressive music, especially in their several interludes, and play it very well. Conductor Cornelius Meister has the measure of the piece, and maintains a good balance between singers and pit ... This largely effective musical realisation could yet be a staging post in what one hopes will be a continuing interest by leading opera houses in the works of Hans Werner Henze".


Diapason

2020 octobre

By

By

Didier van Moere

2020 octobre


Fono Forum

2020 September

By

By

Gerhard Persché

2020 September

"Die Reibungsflächen solcher Concordia discors betont Cornelius Meister am Pult des Staatsorchesters Stuttgart mit Akribie, vermittelt in dieser Live-Einspielung vom Vorjahr aus Stuttgart (in Henzes 1991 revidierter Fassung) den filigranen, kammermusikalisch subtilen, in den Zwischenspielen indes symphonisch stählernen Gestus der Partitur. Robin Adams gibt der Titelfigur herbe Intensität ... Überzeugend auch die beiden Ensemble-Veteranen Helene Schneiderman (Kurfürstin) und Michael Ebbecke (Dörfling)".


BBC music magazine

2020 December

By

By

Steph Power

2020 December

"Kimmig's intriguing modern-day production for Staatsoper Stuttgart sets the drama in an abstract frame that's at once transparent and opaque ... Robin Adams is outstanding as Homburg in an excellent cast ... Conductor Cornelius Meister makes cogent the luminous score, revised in 1991 with a reduced instrumentation".


The gramophone

2020 November

By

By

Peter Quantrill

2020 November

"Editor's choice: The Prince is beautifully pitched by Robin Adams as a Schumannlike character ... His love interest, largely invented by Bachmann, is Princess Natalie, a high lyric soprano part sung with crystalline control by Vera-Lotte Böcker. In her duets with the Prince and the Elector Henze's inspiration rises highest, and this staging rises with him: like few post-war composers he could write opera for characters who change over the course of a couple of hours, who know themselves better at the end of it, and we are changed a little for knowing them".


Fono Forum

2020 Dezember

By

By

Manuel Brug

2020 Dezember

"Hans Werner Henzes Kleist-Vertonung Der Prinz von Homburg ist ein immer noch packendes Kammerspiel ... In dieser Stuttgart Aufzeichnung wird die so theatralische, soghafte musik vom Cornelius Meister als scharfzüngiges preussisches Märchen rhetorisch und klanglich überzeugend zum Tönen gebracht ... Trotzdem gehört diese packende Oper einzig dem Prinzen: Robin Adams macht diesen Träumer als sehr heutigen Nerd mit lyrisch kompaktem Bariton plausibel".