"Their second album plays like a band just happy to be on the bill for a gig, without coming across as slack or bored. It's both scrappy and meticulously made, a tricky balance that Feeble Little Horse executes with confidence. 'Girl with Fish' is short. Its songs are mini-sing-alongs of sarcasm ... Feeble Little Horse saunter through vignettes of longing and disappointment with a silliness and no-fucks-given attitude. The band's guitarists Sebastian Kinsler and Ryan Walchonski fill each song with gritty, pedal-ed out murk. Lydia Slocum's vocals are dry and casual. But all this casualness and fuzzy distortion never makes these songs aimless or airy ... It's the magic of a band with infectious chemistry: they take their local show to a wide audience, but it never feels like it's not at home".