"Following the breakout success of their eponymous debut album, Thee Sacred Souls cemented their following by touring across Europe and the United States numerous times, offering their brand of rootsy retro and Latin soul to growing audiences ... They matured as a unit and developed into one of the tightest trios in pop or R&B ... 'Got a Story to Tell' offers 12 original songs that expand the outfit's emotional and musical reach (...), [with] songwriting influenced by the Motown and Brill Building traditions ... "My Heart Is Drowning" melds polished Motown soul-pop and rocksteady reggae in a startling mix that juxtaposes Lane's soaring falsetto with his backing chorus in a plea for love and understanding. It's the album's finest track. In sum, 'Got a Story to Tell' is a masterpiece of growth, musical integration, and unvarnished emotional truth".