"While much of Springtime Carnivore walks in a Twilight Zone between indie pop and clever appropriations of the past, Morgan does manage to reveal a personality of her own over the course of these 14 tracks, and she comes off as clever, confident, and a sure hand with a tune on this set, while her voice suggests a meeting between Dusty Springfield and Kate Bush (if her voice has less range than the former, she's thankfully less melodramatic than the latter). A smart and resourceful exercise in pop that works on several levels".