"Part II is a vital addition to the autumnal period in Cave's songwriting, beginning with a hesitant attempt at "Skeleton Tree" from 2006 ("Jesus was a liar and a thief", Cave suggests). The final side in both versions offers a full album of unreleased material, all of it vital. In Cave's more recent writing, [Warren] Ellis's experimental flourishes flicker and fizz beneath behind the singer's painful ruminations ..,. The highlight is "Life Per Se", a heavily freighted prayer of pain in which hope endures, just about".