Film / operafilm

Boris Godunov


Reviews (19)


MusicWeb international

2023 September

By

By

Paul Corfield Godfrey

2023 September

"Bryn Terfel as the conscience-stricken Tsar ... his rich tones roll out over Mussorgsky's original orchestration with total control. And his acting is superlative ... The remainder of the singing cast is just as good ... Pappano obtains superlative singing from the chorus ... He also gets enthusiastic playing from the orchestra in a manner which thoroughly justifies Mussorgsky's scoring ... Those who want a video representation of Mussorgsky's initial thoughts on the opera are well served here".


Politiken

d. 3. Oct. 2006

By

By

Jan Jacoby

d. 3. Oct. 2006

"Den anden hovedaktør, koret, synger ligefrem slapt og koncertmæssigt. Mindeværdige er først og fremmest Halfvarsons karakterfulde, dramatisk nærværende og anfægtede bud på en russisk Gurnemanz, og Langridges farlige, intelligent underspillede hofsnog ... Weigles moderigtige askese, der havde retfærdiggjort en ren urversion, placerer dramaet i et nøgent gråt rum med tidløse nutidskostumer tilføjet tsaristiske attributter ... Hele det plumpe billedapparat underminerer det psykologiske spil, som er Musorgskijs geni".


Klassisk

2014, nr. 33

By

By

Steen Chr. Steensen

2014, nr. 33

"Den spanske instruktør Calixto Bieito har ... ført operaen frem til en Putin-nutid med en slipseklædt zar, moderne militær og en punker som folkets repræsentant ... Volden bliver et mål for sig selv for Bieito, og det kommer til at virke påklistret ... Barytonen Alexander Tsymbalyuk fremstiller så gribende denne splittede zar ... De øvrige sangere gør ligeledes stærkt indtryk ... Kent Nagano ... har et godt øre for de klanglige nuancer".


Klassisk

2006, nr. 3

By

By

Steen Chr. Steensen

2006, nr. 3

"Forskere har hele tiden vidst, at der også findes en "Ur-Boris", som ikke blev opført i komponistens levetid ... det er den, der nu foreligger på dvd ... forskellene er så store, at der egentlig er tale om to-tre forskellige operaer ... handlingen lagt til en ikke-defineret nutid ... mere skal der ikke til - resten ligger i personkarateristikken, og dér har Willy Decker sin force. Enhver bevægelse og mimespil bliver eksponeret helt ud i denne fine live-optagelse. Dirigenten Sebastians Weigle sørger for, at alle musikalske detajler træder frem".


Fono Forum

2007 Februar

By

By

Gerhard Persché

2007 Februar

"Mit solch einfachen, atemberaubenden theatralischen Mitteln beschreibt Regisseur Willy Decker die Ereignisse um die Thronbesteigung des Boris Gudonow ... Die eindrücklichste Leistung des Abends bietet Philip Langridge, messerscharf und gefährlich als Schujskij".


BBC music magazine

2023 October

By

By

Christopher Cook (musikanmelder)

2023 October

"Bryn Terfel may be a more baritonal Boris than we have come to expect but it's a compelling performance. This is no psychopath in pursuit of power but a man tender with his children yet terrified at the thought of how he reached the throne. And what luxury to have John Tomlinso as Varlaam the merry monk. But it's the chorus who are the stars in this opera, and what sublime singing Renato Balsadonna coaxes from his Covent Garden cohort".


Klassisk

2023, nr. 71

By

By

Steen Chr. Steensen

2023, nr. 71

"Forestillingen er fra 2016, men den har været værd at vente på. Den britiske instruktør Richard Jones har nemlig skabt en på en gang storladen monumental og indædt psykologisk forestilling ... De store scener, hvor folket lider kollektivt, gør et særligt stærkt indtryk båret frem af Covent Gardens fremragende kor. Men ellers er det barytonen Bryn Terfel, der er det altoverskyggende centrum, og han synger Boris' parti med magtfuld stemme, et plaget udtryk og en voldsom intensitet, som får omgivelserne til at ryste ... Antonio Pappano i orkestergraven fremmaner de ekspressive og til tider ganske rå sider af Mussorgskijt partitur".


Operabladet Ascolta

(2003) 22. årgang nr. 4

By

(2003) 22. årgang nr. 4


Politiken

d. 16. Oct. 2003

By

d. 16. Oct. 2003


The gramophone

2014 May

By

By

Hugo Shirley

2014 May

"The updating seems neither modish nor forced, and is carried out with economy and intelligence ... There's no dip in commitment anywhere in the cast. Tsymbalyuk's Boris, sung in a pleasingly smooth, well-regulated bass, is excellent ... Nagano achieves thrillingly focused results ... Highly recommended".


International record review

2014 April

By

By

Roger Pines

2014 April

"Much to enjoy here, then, but for the original version of this opera, the preferable DVD remains Barcelona's Willy Decker production".


The gramophone

2002 October

By

By

Michael Scott Rohan

2002 October

"Borodina is an ideal Marina beautiful and burnished of tone but chillingly self­absorbed ... Gergievs reading is less brilliant than his recent dual recording often rather soft­centred; but he still brings out the sheer anguished beauty of the score. The excellent stereo soundtrack has also been remastered into DTS surround-sound and very airy and ambient this sounds".


The gramophone

2006 October

By

By

David Fanning

2006 October

"If this mish-mash is somehow meant to unite the historical and the archetypal, then it has to be said that the concept fails miserably in practice, not least because most of the cast seem be unsure of their part in realising it. Admittedly Philip Langridge gives an outstanding portrayal of the scheming Shuisky, and Eric Halvarson and Anatoly Kocherga bring a touch of class to Pimen and Varlaam respectively; but most of the rest are in varying degrees painful to watch ... But this new issue is not recommendable even on that basis".


The gramophone

2012 January

By

By

Mike Ashman

2012 January

"Gianandrea Noseda ... paces and balances Boris most naturally, eschewing brassy climaxes or over-melodramatic spookiness ... The staging of this new production should please traditionalists with its literal evocation of late-16th-century clothing ... Konchalovsky's detailed work with his responsive soloists has some of the over-the-top manic energy of Orson Welles in his Shakespeare films: the glinting, desperate, trapped eyes of Orlin Anastassov's Tsar and the fussy sweat-wiping mannerisms of Peter Bronder's Shuisky create an apt other-worldly presence. Both too are in fine voice".


BBC music magazine

2011 October

By

By

David Nice

2011 October

"Orlin Anastassov makes a rich-voiced but wildly over-the-top Gudonov. Best is Gianandrea Noseda's fluent and urgent conducting".

Vurdering (performance): 3/5.

Vurdering (picture & sound): 4/5.


International record review

2011 October

By

By

John T. Hughes

2011 October

"He sets the action on a sloping stage with virtually no scenery but concentrating strongly on the characters ... The cast has no weaknesses ... I rate the performance highly".


Fono Forum

2023 September

By

By

Manuel Brug

2023 September

"Regisseur Richard Jones besinnt sich auf die bahnbrechende Historizität dieses visionären Stücks und lässt deutlich die Gegenwart durchscheinen. Er ist plakativ grell, erinnert aber auch an Ikonenmalerei ... Das wird moritatenhaft simpel erzählt, fokussiert sich im minimalistischen Spiel und dem suggestiven Gesang Bryn Terfels ... Neben Terfel verblassen die anderen durchaus starken Sänger, nur Antonio Pappano dirigiert einen so düster grossmächtig wie gefährlich gleissenden Mussorgski".


Klassisk

2023, nr. 70

By

By

Andrew Mellor

2023, nr. 70

"En dristig, ny opsætning af den "originale" 1869-version af Mussorgskijs "Borid Godunov" med den store walisiske baryton Bryn Terfel i titelrollen ... "Boris Godunov" er en opera, der byder på fyldig lyd, klingende klokker og korrevolutioner, og den skuffer ikke under Antonio Pappanos ledelse".


The gramophone

2023 September

By

By

Marina Frolova-Walker

2023 September

"It's 'Boris Godunov', but not as we know it. Gone is the grandeur and melodrama, the uprising, the fountains, dancing and the female lead. Even the music is different. As you may have guessed, this is the original 1869 version, rejected by the Russian Imperial Theatres ... The Royal Opera production of 2016 reveals the austere beauty, coherence and symmetry of the original version ... It is an ensemble piece, and as such, this production is an unqualified success ... In all, I am very grateful that we have a well-made recording of this production, which allows us at last to see the 1869 version as an independent work of art that makes sense in its own terms, a testimony to Mussorgsky's genius - unruly but brilliant".