"From 1803 until as recently as 1968 the Prix de Rome was a highly prestigious and much-coveted annual award for French composers ... Ravel's growing reputation as a member of the avant-garde was therefore hardly to his advantage, and may explain why he never won the coveted Premier Grand Prix ... The main course, as it were, of this release consists of the three cantatas, Myrrha (1901), Alcyone (1902) and Alyssa (1903), which BIS group together on Disc 1. However, it's probably logical to deal first with the five short choruses, gathered together on Disc 2, since these, together with the fugues, were positioned as the first hurdle which a Prix de Rome contestant had to clear ... All the solos are well done and the Choeur et Orchestre National des Pays de La Loire provide accomplished performances ... When it comes the three cantatas, BIS have really pushed the boat out with the roster of soloists. These include Véronique Gens ... Pascal Rophé leads performances that put the best possible case for all three scores ... These unfamiliar early Ravel works are shown in the best possible light on these SACDs".