"Since the late '60s, folkies had longed for a collaborative album from Stills and Collins, which was long overdue. What could have been a nice parting gift from two legends from the '60s ended up being the opposite. If nothing else, this album illuminates how strong of vocalists and essential songwriters Stills and Collins were when they were at their pinnacle over 40 years ago. Everybody Knows is an unpleasant reminder that even the greatest singers and songwriters are sometimes unable to age gracefully".