"Vurdering: C" - "The Jekyll and Hyde dichotomy is undoubtedly meant to represent the conflict between Zac Brown Band's more and less traditionalist sides ... Whatever they sound like on a given track, Zac Brown Band's reputation of bucking the Nashville status quo will undoubtedly only deepen after the release of this all-over-the-map record ... The problem with Jekyll + Hyde is that, with a few exceptions, a listener equally unfamiliar with the band and its role in the Nashville music scene can barely hear the difference".