"La donna del lago, premiered at Naples in 1819, one of Rossini's finest scores, is infrequent on modern stages ... The singers are very fine, and several of the best numbers are outstandingly well performed. Both tenors live up to their formidable reputations, and Michael Spyres even gets an ovation to match that of the supremely popular Juan Diego Flórez. Salome Jicia has the measure of the rather tricky role of Elena, who juggles three suitors and needs appropriate responses to each. She also sings superbly, with the tone, range and flexibility for her solos and for her ensemble contributions ... The very fine chorus and orchestra relish their many stirring and colourful moments ... One for the 'La donna del lago' short list, then, especially if one knows the work and is open to the director's unique view".