"Piano Nights heaves its audience into the darkest canals of the group's mystique, where the stylistic tropes are familiar but the forms they assume are not. Of course, the band's persistence is what makes this music "challenging," as opposed to the compositional structures that shape them, but on Piano Nights, those idiosyncrasies are pressed through a grotto of layered instrumentation that reveals an essential addition to the Bohren canon. This is the reason they continue to creep forward, exposing every dimension of their desperate, beautiful sound".