"On his first new album since 2018, the Canadian songwriter with the gentle country lilt laments almost everything ... The hazards hidden inside Paisley's calm have never been as dense and potentially devastating as they are during 'Say What You Like' ... The contrast between his sound and substance has never been more striking, either. Backed on these 11 tracks by versatile Toronto band Bahamas, Paisley is cool above the country funk of "Say What You Like" and "Make It a Double," collected over the spartan "Holy Roller" and "Rewrite History." These songs, though, are a liturgy of grievance and disappointment, Paisley taking aim at old flames and distant friends, his own vaulting ambition or lack thereof ... In another era of country music (admittedly, the one that serves as a primary muse), Paisley's voice might have made him a superstar".