"Shitty Hits is a kaleidoscope in grayscale: creaky chamber-pop, dirge-driven doom-folk, hushed solo piano works. Self-deprecation aside, Von Schleicher has rather sturdy pop instincts, and, as that title would suggest, no qualms about subverting them ... It's a record that revels in contradiction: pop songs too scratchy and subterranean for the radio, pocket orchestras a touch too big for one four-track to contain. Hers aren't "stick in your head" melodies, they're "haunt the edges of your psyche" melodies, buoyed by shoestring arrangements and Von Schleicher's captivating vocals. Equal parts brittle and brazen, Shitty Hits is the work of a well-past-promising newcomer".