"The second album from the crossover star features a few inarguable pop hits, but Post Malone's singular, dour mood wears thin and grows stale after too long ... His best hooks are so tuneful and airless they directly target the ear's pleasure centers. Too often, though, Beerbongs overplays its hand, twisting potentially breezy songs into something false and performative. For an artist whose secret weapon is his light touch, Post Malone lays it on mighty thick".