Musik / klassisk musik 1950 ->

Suite on poems by Michelangelo


Anmeldelser (8)


The guardian

d. 12. nov. 2015

af

af

Erica Jeal

d. 12. nov. 2015

"Hvorostovsky and Ilja capture the right degree of bleakness, anger and intensity. There is something of the iron fist in a velvet glove to Hvorostovsky's voice here, and that velvet thins just often enough to reveal the edge beneath. His baritone may now be a touch too craggy for Liszt's Petrarch Sonnets, but he and Ilja shape them stylishly".


Klassik heute

d. 27. dec. 2015

af

af

Ekkehard Pluta

d. 27. dec. 2015

"Beide Musiker scheinen hier nicht nur dem Dichter, sondern auch dem Bildhauer Michelangelo ihre Reverenz erweisen zu wollen. Der Pianoklang wirkt wie gemeisselt und die ausdrucksstarke vokale Präsenz des Sängers streift gelegentlich das Monumentale ... Nicht ebenso überzeugend ist das opernhafte Pathos in den drei Petrarca-Sonetten von Franz Liszt".


BBC music magazine

2006 February

af

af

David Nice

2006 February

"There's still some way to go with the finish of the phrases, and his [Abdrazakov] rich bass instrument sometimes needs focusing to hit the notes spot-on ... Gianandrea Noseda's BBC Philharmonic set up the necessary atmospheres".


BBC music magazine

2016 March

af

af

David Nice

2016 March

"Hvorostovsky's baritone, still one of the great voices, can combine dark timbre with an emotional warmth to offset the granitic style; while pianist Ivari Ilja, although unable to mimic apocalyptic trumpets at the start of the flickering harp at the end, conjures up all the rest with austere commitment".


Diapason

2016 janvier

af

af

Hélène Cao

2016 janvier


International record review

2006 February

af

af

Carl Rosman

2006 February

"Ildar Abdrazakov and Gianandrea Noseda rightly take a large-scale view of a work in no great need of small-scale histrionics. The BBC Philharmonic proves excellent thoughout, from exposed solo moments to massive tuttis ... Abdrazakov resists the temptation to attempt excessive lightness and the ending is wonderfully shaped".


The gramophone

2006 April

af

af

David Fanning

2006 April

"Full-blooded Shostakovich with a fine young bass ... Abdrazakov's restraint brings its own rewards, allowing the songs to speak with stoical wisdom, the more so thanks to his fabulously steady tone, which remains rich and euphonious across the entire register and dynamic range. The BBC Philharmonic and their principal conductor accompany with refinement and well aimed attack".


The gramophone

2015 December

af

af

Mark Pullinger

2015 December

"Vurdering: Editor's choice" - "There are few things finer than Hvorostovsky in full flight and Liszt's Petrarch Sonnets allow him the chance to open up the Italianate warmth in his baritone, with impassioned accounts, especially of Sonnet 47".