"'After Dinner We Talk Dreams' is a sonically cohesive listen, which is all the more impressive when considering that the album came together after three years of stop-and-start writing. While this means that some songs get lost in the shuffle, a little too same-y for the casual listener, on the whole, the 14 tracks blossom with chill bangers that make the most of Michelle's honeyed vocals ... Listening to the record, it's so clear how much fun the band have writing and performing together. "Talking To Myself" has hints of Corinne Bailey Rae, thanks to sunny guitar and lyrics like, "You can keep the toaster / Leave me with the breadcrumbs," but bubbly synth and goofy vocalization at the end mark the song as undeniably Michelle's ... Michelle are one of the most underrated New York bands of the last few years, but hopefully their exquisite harmonies and groovy pop hooks on 'After Dinner we Talk Dreams' will draw in new fans. By connecting so well with one another, Michelle reach listeners in a singular and effortlessly listenable way".