"[Producer Chuck] Ainlay provides just the slightest hint of contemporization, opening up the mix a bit and adding splashes of handsomely burnished color, subtle - almost imperceptible - changes that nevertheless freshen Strait's proudly traditional country without pushing it into a cacophonous modern mainstream ... Still, what holds the album together is Strait's mellow command. He's a singer that can make quiet seem compelling, and there are plenty of instances in this tight, wholly satisfying record where he demands attention by not asking for it".