"Island Intervals starts with songs that pit the intimate and the epic against each other, that shift tempo, texture, and scope in fascinating ways. But that set of complications can't sustain itself. It doesn't help that the words themselves feel overworked ... The shift into the shadows works in parts for Thibodeau, but the album doesn't want to linger in that dark so much as obliterate it with a light we've heard from him before. That would be all right, but here some of the songs get buried in the process".