Music / operafilm

Les pêcheurs de perles


Reviews (8)


Classics today

2008

By

By

Robert Levine (musikanmelder)

2008

"The production is quite handsome ... Although there's nothing particularly realistic about any of it, the staging works well, giving off just the right exotic aura ... it's a fine performance, the tenor notwithstanding".


MusicWeb international

2008 January

By

By

Robert McKechnie

2008 January

"There is so much that is stunningly good in this production ... Unfortunately the pacing is uneven".


Kristeligt dagblad

d. 9. Mar. 2017

By

By

Peter Dürrfeld

d. 9. Mar. 2017

"Handlingen foregår blandt perlefiskere på Ceylon, og i de to første akter kan man nyde den opulente regi, som The Met er så kendt for. I terrasseformede omgivelser ser man små hytter, et lille Brahma-tempel - og man godtager det som Ceylon for er par århundreder siden. Men i tredje akt skifter regien helt karakter, nu befinder man sig i et nyere overdimensioneret arkivlokale. Perlefiskernes leder, Zurga har en bærbar computer stående på sit skrivebord ... Et sceneskift, der er svært at sluge for denne anmelder - regissøren har efter min opfattelse i den grad sat sig mellem to stole. Enten skal man opdatere eller lade være".


Diapason

2017 mars

By

By

François Laurent

2017 mars


BBC music magazine

2017 April

By

By

Christopher Cook (musikanmelder)

2017 April

"Updated to Sri Lanka and located in a shanty village clinging to the seashore Woolcock finds a double drama in Bizet's opera ... The sea is evident in the music, Gianandrea Noseda drawing sumptuous playing from the Met Orchestra ... The Met fields a magnificent cast ... But it's Diana Damrau's Leïla who steals the audience's heart ... Her appeal to Zurga to spare Nadir's life would make the very pebbles on the seashore weep".


BBC music magazine

2015 March

By

By

Michael Scott Rohan

2015 March

"The performances are mostly more than acceptable, despite some truly appallingly accented French ... So if it's the familiar duet you want, go for this new recording".


Fono Forum

2017 März

By

By

Manuel Brug

2017 März

"Nicht nur die Deutsche [Damrau] wurde für ihre festen Höhen und ihr sensibles Spiel gefeiert, auch die Männer sind grossartig. Gianandrea Noseda dirigiert die auf Sri Lanka spielende, gar nicht exotisch klingende Partitur mit Liebe und Finesse".


The gramophone

2017 April

By

By

Richard Lawrence

2017 April

"In this performance ... the setting is not Ceylon in ancient times. We are in present-day Sri Lanka: a shanty town on the sea shore ... The action opens with a lively, nervy chorus ... Diana Damrau is lightness itself in her song to the gods ... Bizet's storm music when the lovers are discovered is not very inspired, but Gianandrea Noseda gets vivid singing and playing from the chorus and orchestra ... Kwiecien is superb ... The opera is no masterpiece, but this production should win it many new friends".