"Shout!'s problems are virtually all on its no-extra-charge bonus disc. It features the same tracks in different order, with the band fronted by all-star guests. While some tunes work, most do not ... Shout! would have been better served if the best of the guest performances were integrated into the formal album. For fans, the first disc has plenty of exciting material to offer: it sounds great, the writing is excellent, there are new musical directions, and, as expected, there is terrific playing throughout".