"Every so often, Teenage Bottlerocket break down their tongue-in-cheek demeanour and offer something a little more earnest. The delightful "Can't Quit You," and the album's closer "First Time," wear their heart on their leather-clad sleeves, and give the record some depth, an element the rest of the album has in short supply. Tales From Wyoming stays safely in the established genre without trying to be groundbreaking, but simplicity and quirky immaturity are the bread and butter of pop punk, and there's enough to satisfy here".