"The hours spent working on their sound definitely paid off, and the choice to keep the production streamlined and simple works. The lack of studio glop helps keep the record grounded and very real sounding, and Horsegirl are nothing if not authentic. They've tapped into the source of indie rock's greatness like few bands have been able to, and Versions of Modern Performance isn't merely a homage or a neat trick, it's another very strong, very satisfying link in the chain connecting past to present".