Don Juan
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
Emneord
Anmeldelser (13)
Kulturradio RBB
d. 10. maj 2017
af
af
Kai Luehrs-Kaiser
d. 10. maj 2017
"Dieses Gesamtprojekt [von Opern Jean-Baptiste Lullys] darf ohne Weiteres als epochal gewertet werden, zumal sich noch kein Dirigent so systematisch mit dem Hofkomponisten Ludwigs XIV. überhaupt befasst hat ... Das Werk erweckt einen viel mürberen, fragileren, psychologisch sensibleren Eindruck als zuvor ... Allerspätestens dann wird diese Aufnahme als Meilenstein gelten".
MusicWeb international
2020 November
af
af
Stuart Sillitoe
2020 November
"Recommended: Hervé Niquet made a wonderful recording of Persée (1770) ... This is another remarkable performance. Chief amongst the plaudits must go to Véronique Gens. She shows that she is destined to play Armide. Her performance is flawless and characterful ... Other soloists are equally well cast ... The chorus is a big part of the production. I am glad to say that the colourful performance of the choir of the ensemble Le Concert Spirituel proves that they are more than up to the task. The orchestra of Le Concert Spirituel gives great support. They once again show that they are one of the preeminent ensembles in the French baroque repertoire ... Hervé Niquet ... directs this opera with great panache, and gives the work a sense of real presence. This is definitely a performance to enjoy and savour ... A clear winner".
MusicWeb international
2017 June
af
af
Simon Thompson (musikanmelder)
2017 June
"Recording of the month: Rousset is, of course, a whizz with this sort of repertoire, and he has the finest feeling for this whole lost musical world ... There is tremendous class and élan throughout ... Rousset brilliantly recaptures the feel of the French court as though it were all in a day's work ... The cast of singers he has assembled is formidable, and worthy of the challenge. In particular, Marie-Adeline Henry in the title role has a magnificent sit-up-and-take-notice quality to her voice".
MusicWeb international
2008 December
af
af
Robert Hugill
2008 December
"My recommendation is to go hunting for Herreweghe’s disc, where for my money, the style is better and far more apposite. Brown and his forces give you a creditable and approachable version of the opera; Herreweghe gives you a powerfully moving one".
BBC music magazine
2020 November
af
af
Berta Joncus
2020 November
"Recording of the month: This project's performers are, from first note to last, as outstanding as the score. Véronique Gens delivers a career-defining performance as Armide, a sorceress and seductress of volcanic power ... Armide's character fits Gens like a glove: her sexy, dark-hued instrument, blistering line and dramatic intensity project a woman both commanding and vulnerable ... Niquet is also enchanting ... thanks to the mix of muscle and talent at Niquet's disposal - his orchestra has 33 players; his chorus, 26 singers ... All vocal soloists shine in turn ... Reinoud Van Mechelen as Renaud stands out ... This Armide is among the most brilliant opera projects of recent years".
Fono Forum
2021 Januar
af
af
Bernd Feuchtner
2021 Januar
"Armide 1778? Lully starb doch schon 1687! Paris war das erste Opernhaus, das ein Repertoir pflegte, und in dieses geheiligte Erbe war 1777 Gluck mit seiner "Armide" vorgestossen. Da betraute die Opéra Louis-Joseph Franceour mit einer Überarbeitung von Lullys Partitur ... Veronique Gens profitiert von Francoeurs überarbeitung der Titelpartie in Richtung auf den heroischen Stil Glucks ... und Tassis Christoyannis ist da für Gens ein brillant-finsterer Sparringspartner ... Dieses Hybrid zwischen Lully und Gluck behauptet seinen eigenen Rang".
Diapason
2020 septembre
af
af
Loïc Chahine
2020 septembre
BBC music magazine
2017 August
af
af
Anna Picard
2017 August
"It is no accident that the most-recorded sections of Armide are the anti-heroine's monologues. In Christophe Rousset's exquisitely produced live recording, these are delivered with appropriate ferocity and charisma by Marie-Adeline Henry. The orchestral accompaniment is vivacious, with attentive and imaginative continuo playing, plenty of bite from the strings, and even more bite when La Haine (an abrasive Marc Mauillon) appears".
Fono Forum
2017 August
af
af
Gerhard Persché
2017 August
"Christophe Rousset ... interpretiert die Partitur ohne dynamische und agogische Übertreibungen, jedoch sensibel, mit psykologischem Feingefühl und viel Aufmerksamkeit fürs Detail. Marie-Adeline Henry singt die Titelpartie mit ihrer charakteristischen Stimme überzeugend ... und auch die anderen sind vorzüglich".
Diapason
2017 mai
af
af
Jean-Philippe Grosperrin
2017 mai
Diapason
2009 janvier
af
af
Piotr Kaminski
2009 janvier
The gramophone
2020 October
af
af
Richard Lawrence
2020 October
"The story is a splendid vehicle for Véronique Gens ... She is in glorious voice ... Van Mechelen is ideal as his namesake, mellifluous and attentive to the text. The other singers, familiar specialists in this repertoire, are excellent, Tassis Christoyannis especially robust in the extended scene for Hate. Le Concert Spirituel and Hervé Niquet are in fine form".
The gramophone
2017 July
af
af
David Vickers
2017 July
"Editor's choice: Les Talens Lyriques play with consummate mastery of elegantly swaying inégales, fizzy brilliance or suave dancelike gestures as each moment in Lully's score demands ... Marie-Adelaide Henry captures the full measure of Armide's conflicting emotions, and the undercurrent of theatrical tensions produced by Rousset and his band indicates why Rameau judged this sensational music to be worthy of analytical praise".