"This meeting of two masters of their respective realms is a spine-tingling triumph - a honky, gutsy, jaunty, darkly witty new musical alloy that is suitably strange yet strangely familiar ... It takes more than virtuosity to make music send shivers down your spine. You need generosity and vision, impeccable taste and a willingness to take risks. Still, the fact that Thile and Mehldau are as fine a pair of instrumentalists as you'll hear anywhere doesn't hurt a bit".