"The down side is that at just a dozen selections filling 44 minutes, there is room for nearly twice as much music. While May the Circle Remain Unbroken is a wonderful and long overdue companion to the earlier anthology, perhaps this can be an ongoing project".
" The covers favour Erickson's more introspective solo works over his garage-y nuggets, though Ty Segall's needles-in-the-red Night Of The Vampire impressively out-weirds the original, preserving its pin-eyed sense of panic. Meanwhile, Lucinda Williams clearly relishes her every berserk snarl on You're Gonna Miss Me - and her glee is infectious".