""Nine Pin" is a more assured, jazz-inflected record than its predecessor, though there's still plenty of traditional Appalachian material here ... It's Kaia Kater's own songs that impress the most - the subtle interplay of electric guitar and trumpet on "Sain Elizabeth", the stately, hypnotic piano and pizzicao ciolin of "Viper's Nest", and the echoing dance steps that provide the sole accompaniment to "Harlem's Little Blackbird" ... Kater doesn't write proselytising protest songs, but she isn't afraid to plainly articulate uncomfortable truths - "Your cross is a symbol of my lynching" - "In this town I am meat for the taking" ... She's grown, not just as a songwriter, but as a singer too, and her voice has acquired an irresistible richness. It's possible that a little more time spent in the studio might have resulted in something even more impressive, but Kater's boldness confirms her continuaing emergence as an artist of real stature".