12 years a slave
Steve McQueen
Emneord
Minder om
Anmeldelser (7)
MusicWeb international
2006 August
af
af
Patrick C. Waller
2006 August
"The playing was predictably superb. There seemed to be a very high level of rapport between conductor and orchestra, and Bernstein was clearly inspirational to the orchestra ... There is not a great deal to say about picture and sound quality which are pretty standard for the medium and do not draw attention to themselves".
BBC music magazine
2016 June
af
af
Michael Tanner (musikanmelder)
2016 June
"Here are two magnificent accounts of Bruckner's Ninth Symphony, one of the most difficult works in the repertoire to bring off in all its terrifying power. They are both led by high-profile conductors, but very different ones ... In the demonic Scherzo ... Mariss Jansons is slightly more powerful than Christian Thielemann ... [But in] the last movement ... Thielemann left me a prostrate supplicant for mercy, while Jansons only produces a striking effect".
Diapason
2016 decembre
af
af
Jean-Claude Hulot
2016 decembre
Financial Times
d. 18. apr. 2015
af
af
Richard Fairman
d. 18. apr. 2015
"The performance is grand without being portentous, impassioned but never febrile, and is distinguished by a poised musicianship in the finest classical tradition. The DVD filming, like the playing, is devoid of tricksy effects".
Klassisk
2015, nr. 37
af
af
Steen Chr. Steensen
2015, nr. 37
"Symfonien kan på afstand virke gigantisk, næsten uoverstigelig, men med Barenboims suveræne overblik og indsigt åbner værket sig i dets uendelige rigdom ... Barenboim har en helt usædvanlig evne til at ... lade musikken vokse ud af netop ingenting i den store filharmoniske sal i Berlin. Denne dvd-udgave har et fortryllelsens skær over sig, når den sortklædte Barenboim står som en anden troldmand og griber og dirigerer tonerne til live ... Bruckners 9. symfoni fremstår her i et nyt forklarelsens lys".
The gramophone
2016 April
af
af
Christian Hoskins
2016 April
"Thielemann solicits typical warmth and richness from the Dresden orchestra, the woodwinds in particular on fine form".
International record review
2006 September
af
af
Nigel Simeone
2006 September
"My own response is overwhelmingly positive: I find Bernsteins's Bruckner to be an utterly gripping and emotionally involving experinece, a glorious, big-hearted alternative to those accounts of this work which treat his music as if it is a symphonic equivalent of momumental masonry".