Musik / operafilm

The gambler


Anmeldelser (8)


BBC music magazine

2013 October

af

af

David Nice

2013 October

"Gergiev conducts with exemplary clarity but not the requisite volatility".


Opus

2013, nr. 50

af

af

Axel Lindhe

2013, nr. 50

"Låt nu inte en rörig handling avskräcka ... för det här är riktigt bra ... På scenen huserar en förstklassig sångarensemble med den karismatiske Vladimir Galuzin i huvudrollen ... Man är garanterad en underhållande stund framför tv:n".


Diapason

2013 septembre

af

af

Benoît Fauchet

2013 septembre


Klassisk

2010, nr. 18

af

af

Steen Chr. Steensen

2010, nr. 18

"At han virkelig respekterer Prokofievs partitur er tydeligt. Barenboim dirigerer dynamisk og lydhørt for alle detaljer i en musik, der bestandig skifter karakter ... Scenen er en række blå rum, som publikum kan kigge ind i som var det akvarier ... Persongalleriet er så præcist at opsætningen rammer ind i det centrale i operaen: skildringen af en række mennesker i afmagt".


The gramophone

2013 Awards

af

af

Richard Fairman

2013 Awards

"The stage production by Temur Chkheidze is simple and straightforward ... The cast is a decent one overall, with Tatiana Pavlovskaya making a glamorous Polina, Sergei Aleksashkin an old bumbler as the General, and Nikolai Gassiev and Alexander Gergalov both nicely suave as the Marquis and Mr Astley".


International record review

2013 September

af

af

Roger Pines

2013 September

"The Mariinsky players are at their most impressive, and Valery Gergiev sustains Prokofiev's driving energy from start to finish with a theatrical force that I had frankly not expected in this work".


The gramophone

2010 July

af

af

David Gutman

2010 July

"Vurdering: Dvd of the month" - "Detailed stage design and committed performances make this worth a gamble ... Strongly recommended".


BBC music magazine

2010 June

af

af

David Nice

2010 June

"Tcherniakov's line is a demanding contemporary realism, giving his singer-actors detailed physical gestures so they stop trying too hard to be naturalistic ... Barenboim's crystal-clear pacing of the score is hard-hitting rather that quicksilvery, but the payoff in the last Act is terrific".

Vurdering (performance): 5/5.

Vurdering (picture & sound): 5/5.