Music / klassiske symfonier

La tragédie de Salomé


Reviews (10)


The guardian

d. 30. June 2011

By

By

Andrew Clements (musikanmelder)

d. 30. June 2011

"Its subterranean colours and mood sometimes recall Debussy's Pelléas et Mélisande, while the transparency of the scoring owes something to Dukas's Sorcerer's Apprentice. It's fluently done, and a perfect piece for a musical quiz - the composer would be hard to identify other than as French".


Presto classical

d. 30. Nov. 2020

By

By

Katherine Cooper

d. 30. Nov. 2020

"Editor's choices - November 2020: The Buffalo players sound terrific in Schmitt's two large-scale 'Orientalist' ballet suites, with a fabulously glossy proto-Hollywood sheen to the strings and some especially characterful playing from the cor anglais and trumpets; Falletta is mindful of both works' origins in dance, and achieves a lovely shimmering transparency in passages that could easily seem overblown. It's also great to hear the world premiere recording of the orchestral version of Musique sur l'eau, composed in 1898 and orchestrated fifteen years later, which has more than a whisper of Debussy's La mer about it".


Presto classical

d. 17. May 2024

By

By

James Longstaffe

d. 17. May 2024

"Recording of the week: This outstanding new performance from Alain Altinoglu and the Frankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra joins an extremely small number of recordings of the original, full-length version, and it is most certainly a sumptuous treat. It's such a vivid score, all brought out beautifully by Altinoglu and his players".


BBC music magazine

2021 January

By

By

Roger Nichols (musikanmelder)

2021 January

"These four works covering some 40 years of Schmitt's long career, display his magisterial writing for orchestra, full of varied colours and equally satisfying in the quieter, more delicate moments ... Beautifully sung by Susan Platts, it [Musique sur l'eau] is one of the highlights of this interesting disc".


Fono Forum

2024 September

By

By

Michael Kube

2024 September


BBC music magazine

2011 July

By

By

Terry Blain

2011 July

"Vurdering: BBC Music choral song choice" - "This is a super CD and an ideal introduction to the perilously seductive sound-world of this composer".


The gramophone

2021 February

By

By

Christian Hoskins

2021 February

"There's no shortage of recordings of [La tragédie de Salomé], including excellent versions by Jean Martinon and Yan Pascal Tortelier, but Falletta's version communicates the atmosphere, luxuriousness and power of Schmitt's score as well as any ... The solo part [of the Légende] is performed by the Buffalo Philharmonic's concertmaster Nikki Chooi with total conviction and assurance. Altogether a most desirable release".


The gramophone

2024 July

By

By

Richard Whitehouse

2024 July

"Alain Alitnoglu is a persuasive guide and the Frankfurt Radio Symphony have its measure more fully than versions conducted by Patrick Davin or Julien Masmondet ... For this score, as Schmitt conceived it, Altinoglu is selfevidently the first choice".


International record review

2011 April

By

By

Mark Pullinger

2011 April

"The Orchestre Métropolitain is not too dissimilar to its more illustrious Montréal neighbours under Charles Dutoit - brass playing on the polite side, matched by refined string playing ... If the coupling appeals, or if you wish to familiarize yourself with this young conductor's work (and he's worth following), then this is a recommendable disc".


The gramophone

2011 June

By

By

Geoffrey Norris

2011 June

"Vurdering: E (Editor's choice)" - "Nézet-Séguin has a strong grasp of the symphony's structure, its ebb and flow of dynamics and pace, and its rich spectrum of orchestral colouring".