"Still, the album holds onto the band's best moves - foot-stomping anthems with a home in packed stadiums ("Lift Me Up" and "Heaven") and ballads with soaring choruses ("Born" and "Fingertips"). In these lies the heart of OneRepublic, a distillation of Tedder's influence and his influences. It's a potpourri formula that, with Oh My My, hasn't lost its fragrance".