"Lady A take few risks on any of the 12 songs on 'On This Winter's Night.' Only 'Blue Christmas' is a marked deviation from the original ... The title track is truly the album's highlight — the star at the top of a tree filled with familiar ornaments".
"Gabende elevator-julehygge fra country-pop-trioen fra Nashville ... Der er simpelthen for mange bløde musikalske pakker under Lady Antebellums plasticjuletræ, og sangene kan absolut opleves i mere interessante udgaver på mange af de andre juleudgivelser derude".