"Athanaël is sung extremely well by baritone Joshua Hopkins ... Andrew Staples is a most accomplished tenor ... Then, Erin Wall as Thaïs is really, really good, and it is only in comparison with the luxuriant voice of Renée Fleming that any criticism can be levelled ... Andre Davis paces the opera perfectly and the orchestra play splendidly. The large chorus also fulfils its rôle to perfection, and all the minor parts are sung very well indeed; there is not a weakness anywhere".