"The Hallé choir ... is fine at either extreme ... Mark Elder here as elsewhere feeling the sheer stillness that is sometimes at the centre of this nevertheless impassioned score. He also coaxes some magical playing from the Hallé players ... As the baritone narrator, Roderick Williams, similarly attentive, though less weighty than Bryn Terfel, quite English-sounding ... does a fine job ... The Hallé is still near the top of the league".