"These 11 songs encompass Scottish writers from Ivor Cutler to Biffy Clyro, via the more predictable Waterboys and Deacon Blue. So far, so under-whelming, but there's coherence and magic here. Polwart gives Chvrches' "The Mother We Share" a finger-clicking, synth-free makeover; she delivers "CHance", Big Country's anthem for the broken, with heart-stopping tenderness and she coats John Martyn's "Don't Want To Know"with a new layer of menace ... If there must be covers albums, they might as well be as beguiling as this".