Musik / folk

Karine Polwart's Scottish songbook


Anmeldelser (3)


The observer

d. 4. aug. 2019

af

af

Neil Spencer

d. 4. aug. 2019

"The C90 cassette unspooling on the sleeve makes an apt motif for an album that is both a tribute to Scottish pop and a personal testimony from Caledonia's reigning folk queen. Not that there's much folk involved; most of the songs Karine Polwart interprets here are from the mainstream, drawn from a live show in turn inspired by an Edinburgh exhibition ...".


Louder than war

d. 22. juli 2019

af

af

Mike Ainscoe

d. 22. juli 2019

"How do you follow up Mojo's Folk Album Of The Year? Even we were very taken with 2018's "sublime" Laws Of Motion - reviewed here. It's a common occurrence in the folk genre to see artists regularly interpret traditional song so here's a variation on the norm with Karine doing what most would call a covers album. One that spans fifty years of Scottish pop ... It's a well thought out concept that could have resulted in a routine collection, but executed consummately".


Mojo

2019 September

af

af

John Aizlewood

2019 September

"These 11 songs encompass Scottish writers from Ivor Cutler to Biffy Clyro, via the more predictable Waterboys and Deacon Blue. So far, so under-whelming, but there's coherence and magic here. Polwart gives Chvrches' "The Mother We Share" a finger-clicking, synth-free makeover; she delivers "CHance", Big Country's anthem for the broken, with heart-stopping tenderness and she coats John Martyn's "Don't Want To Know"with a new layer of menace ... If there must be covers albums, they might as well be as beguiling as this".