"For a band primarily known for their rootsy acoustic ramblings prior to Magic Fire, they've flipped the formula straight on its head for their fifth consecutive release and their first in two solid years. Not only is their production value much more refined [...] but their sound, at an intrinsic level, has been expanded upon greatly with the introduction of the collaborative nature of the album ... Ultimately, it makes for a much different experience than their thoroughly celebrated Best Medicine [...] but one with as much quality as one would have deduced the band would strive for since their beginnings".