Pitchforkd. 24. maj 2017afafStuart Bermand. 24. maj 2017"The new !!! album finds them working with a slew of guest singers, exploring twitchy R&B, queasy dub-disco, romantic house, and more. As ever, their dance music is both celebratory and unsentimental".Læs anmeldelse
Exclaim!d. 19. maj 2017afafIan Gormelyd. 19. maj 2017"Shake the Shudder is the band's closest nod to its disco roots, right down to the mix of female singers who trade lines with frenetic frontman Nick Offer, and mixing farmed out to dance producers like Joakim and Phil Moffa".Læs anmeldelse
AllMusic2017afafTim Sendra2017"!!! have come a long way from their beginnings but also stayed remarkably the same. Shake the Shudder is the work of a band that know exactly what works for them, while still being willing to try new things. It's a winning combination of past, present, and future that bodes well for !!!'s future making plenty more great albums like it as they continue to be one of the last great dance-punk bands of the '90s left standing".Læs anmeldelse