"The layered groove on Time Is Over One Day Old is notably smoother, less showy than on their last album I Love You, It's Cool, but is still definitely a groove. It's overall sadder, gentler, but still on the move, even in its stillest moments. The first track "Autumn" instantly puts me in dance-music mode. But not in an escapist, let-yourself-go way; more like you're stuck in a trance and can't break free. That feeling resonates with the lyrics, describing a pressure that's bearing down, a rumbling coming from your chest ... On Time Is Over One Day Old, there's always something missing, a mystery hanging in the air, yet it's the band's most satisfying album yet".