"The album, in this way, is much like its title, When I Say to You Black Lightning: a directive that invites the listener to fill in what Naggar has initiated or gestured toward; it's a risky invitation, in that it requires effort and attention from the listener, but Naggar's rickety orchestration, imagistic lyrics and posture of kindness ensure that it never feels like effort, so much as a joyful, sad, funny, wise conversation with close, thoughtful friend".