Music / opera

Acis and Galatea


Reviews (16)


Classics today

2019

By

By

Robert Levine (musikanmelder)

2019

"Fine performances of Handel's delightful, brief pastoral are not rare ... Add this new winner under the baton of Harry Christophers and you find quite a recorded legacy ... A wonderful quintet of singers illuminates all of Handel's music. Grace Davidson's pure-as-snow soprano ... Jeremy Budd's light but centered tenor ... But all ears fall to Stuart Young's buffoon-like, murdering Polyphemus ... through his big sopranino recorder-accompanied aria and his part in the pre-murder trio ... The slimmed down forces, by the way, are in line with Handel's first performance of the work".


Classics today

2018

By

By

Robert Levine (musikanmelder)

2018

"This performance replaces the John Eliot Gardiner as my new No. 1 Acis ... This brief work was the composer's most popular during his lifetime: the quick, charming, and eventually touching libretto ... is more than supported by Handel's crisp, memorable tunes that even at their most sentimental are never maudlin, and at their jolliest are truly toe-tapping ... Christian Curnyn leads with zip and sharp ... Tenor Allan Clayton is the least drippy Acis on disc, and in "Love in her eyes sits playing" sounds utterly enthralled with the love of his Galatea. And who wouldn't, in Lucy Crowe's performance ... Sound is wonderfully warm and realistic. Buy this".


classicalsource.com

2018 July

By

By

Curtis Rogers

2018 July

"[From] this charming masque - perhaps Handel's most ravishing score ... comes this equally vivid interpretation with the handful of roles well-characterised, and the score enlivened by the crisp and spirited rhythmic articulation by Christian Curnyn and the Early Opera Company ... Overall there is freshness to Curnyn's direction that evokes appropriately the Arcadian world of an innocent love-story murderously interrupted by the jealous Cyclops Polyphemus ... Allan Clayton brings Acis to life with his warmly ardent, mellifluous singing ... Likewise Lucy Crowe combines assurance and control as his lover, the nymph Galatea, with a musical delicacy ... Neal Davies provides fearful heft as Polyphemus".


MusicWeb international

2018 June

By

By

Dave Billinge

2018 June

"Recording of the month: Acis and Galatea ... was Handel's first major dramatic composition in English and is very effective indeed ... The Early Opera Company gets by with five soloists, bolstered by one extra voice in the choruses, and just sixteen instrumentalists drawn from the UK's pool of wonderful baroque specialists - unsung heroes all. It is gripping from beginning to end ... Neal Davies rages superbly as Polyphemus ... Lucy Crowe as Galatea is gorgeous ... The pairs of recorders and oboes twitter joyfully from the presto opening sinfonia ... I have previously enjoyed John Eliot Gardiner and the English Baroque soloists on a decades-old (1978) pair of Gramophone Award-winning Archiv LPs but this is its match in every respect".


BBC music magazine

2009 January

By

By

George Hall (musikanmelder)

2009 January

"The chief strength of this account lies in the excellent instrumental playing ... Overall a good version, though several better it, notably William Christie's on Erato".


BBC music magazine

2019 May

By

By

George Hall (musikanmelder)

2019 May

"Without undue hurry, [Christophers] keeps the delightful score bouncing merrily along; the instrumentalists supply expert playing ... Grace Davidson's Galatea offers a small but pretty soprano and Jeremy Budd's Acis is crisply articulated and emotionally engaged, while Stuart Young enjoys the comic-grotesque possibilities of the giant Polyphemus".


Fono Forum

2019 Juni

By

By

Reinmar Emans

2019 Juni

"Nach einer arg flotten Sinfonia gelingt es gleichwohl, eine schöne pastorale Stimmung aufzubauen. Als einzige Sängerin weiss Grace Davidson mit modifizierbaren Timbres und klarer Stimme zu überzeugen ... Die Tenöre sind grossartig besetzt. Alle Singen sehr klar und können trotz ihrer deutlich differenzierbaren Timbres eine recht grosse Strahlkraft entfalten".


BBC music magazine

2018 August

By

By

Berta Joncus

2018 August

"Curnyn has hit on a secret that eluded previous interpreters of this work: it was conceived specifically to showcase the beauty of the English language ... Channelling Handel's enthusiasm, Curnyn and his fellow artists forge a musical rhetoric powered by native sonorities ... Lucy Crowe as Galatea excels especially in turning words, and word-pictures, into sound ... This is, altogether, a benchmark that will be hard to beat".


Diapason

2016 fevrier

By

By

Ivan A. Alexandre

2016 fevrier


Fono Forum

2016 Februar

By

By

Matthias Hengelbrock

2016 Februar

"Teresa Wakim und aron Shehan geben ein überzeugendes Liebespaar ab, aber Douglas Williams ist stimmlich für die Partie des polternden Polyphem viel zu schwach".


International record review

2008 December

By

By

Peter Branscombe

2008 December

"Linn provides an attractive booklet to accompany the outstanding new recording ... The recording ... is spacious ans well balanced. This issue is warmly recommended".


The gramophone

2009 January

By

By

David Vickers

2009 January

"Vurdering: Recording of the month - Vurdering: Editor's choice" - "A magical performance of the fully-realised Cannons Acis ... The five singers and the band are beautifully in proportion with each other, and Linn's sound recording is stunningly good".


The gramophone

2019 April

By

By

Lindsay Kemp

2019 April

"There is no doubt that the smaller forces bring not only greater clarity and sweetness but also uplifting drafts of clean air that seem entirely appropriate to the work ... The singers are not the operatically outgoing sort. Rather, they offer uncomplicated vocal beauty and intimacy ... Stuart Young's Polyphemus, indeed, provides the most impressive singing and acting here, conjuring a monster who roars and blusters but stops short of pantomime villainy ... This one has its charms, for sure, but not everyone will want things to be quite so relaxed".


The gramophone

2018 August

By

By

Richard Lawrence

2018 August

"Acis and Galatea is not an opera, but it can be - and has been - staged ... The pastoral story tells of Galatea's rejection of Polyphemus: the giant take furious revenge by murdering Acis ... Handel's characterisation is brilliant ... Christian Curnyn conducts unobtrusively in the main, which I mean as high praise ... Lucy Crowe is an enchanting Galatea: warm and womanly ... Tenderness - without regret - is the hallmark of Allan Clayton's Acis ... and his tone is always beautiful ... Neal Davies, less lumbering than some, almost makes Polyphemus a credible suitor ... This new [recording] by The Early Opera Company has the edge".


The gramophone

2016 March

By

By

David Vickers

2016 March

"Whatever genre it is, it's certainly one of Handel's loveliest works ... The musical direction of Paul O'Dette and Stephen Stubbs strikes an intelligent balance between sheer delectability and the astute dramatisation of moods such as playfulness ".


Politiken

d. 10. Oct. 1999

By

d. 10. Oct. 1999