"This is the band's most rock-ready work to date, unafraid of embracing Southern rock standards to influence their sound more directly than in the past. Holding All the Roses, is, by a solid country mile, Blackberry Smoke's most cohesive release yet, taking an overarching anthem-ridden, country-sensible style and tinging it with a production equally as clean as it is pleasingly raw. From the starting moments of lead single and album opener "Let Me Help You (Find the Door)" and its humorously gratifying anti-mainstream sentimentality, through the slow-burning, album-closing torch song "Fire in the Hole", the LP holds up amazingly well".