"DiFranco's songs here employ a strategy she's not used often: Abundant lyric repetition. It roots these songs closer in spirit and form to folk, blues, and gospel traditions. Since they are less dense and more experiential, emotional authority is articulated in each line. DiFranco's mix, for all its space and texture, is one of tasteful restraint. It allows melodic and rhythmic invention to shine through, underscoring the skill in her composing and the quality of the instrumental performances. In a catalog that contains over 20 studio albums, Allergic to Water is exemplary for its craft".