"Recorded live, often in first takes, this is an album of timeless American songwriting informed by the past but not beholden to it. When Shelley's ineffable voice dips unwxpectedly in "Where I'll Find You", or shifts effortlessly into upper register over the sparse but utterly apt accompaniment of "Even Though", the listener isn't merely impressed by her technique, but enraptured by her confessional, emotionally engaging songs".