Musik / opera

Le timbre d'argent


Anmeldelser (5)


MusicWeb international

2020 September

af

af

Michael Cookson

2020 September

"Saint-Saëns described Le Timbre d'argent as containing 'a bit of everything... ranging from symphony to operetta by way of a lyric drama and ballet' and occasional shades of musical theatre. As if doomed to failure, the opera has certainly had more than its fair share of trials and tribulations. Running such a convoluted course, Le Timbre d'argent with all its transformations has certainly been worth all the effort to arrive at its 2017 revival. Far more than a mere historical novelty, this captivating recording shows that Bru Zane has unearthed a valuable opera to cherish".


Presto classical

d. 31. aug. 2020

af

af

Katherine Cooper

d. 31. aug. 2020

"Editor's choices - August 2020: Gothic goings-on of a more extravagant nature also abound in Saint-Saëns's first opera (given here in its final, 1914 version), and Roth and his period band rise to the occasion with just the right amount of Grand Guignol roughness around the edges; the plot may look forward to Offenbach's Les contes d'Hoffmann, but the manic energy of the score has more than a whiff of Berlioz, and in particular the Symphonie fantastique. Montvidas, also a fine Hoffmann, is superb as the feverish artist who strikes a devilish bargain - or does he?".


BBC music magazine

2020 November

af

af

Christopher Cook (musikanmelder)

2020 November

"The score is as elegantly upholstered as anything that Saint-Säens wrote ... Fiametta is a danced role which leaves something of a vocal hole in the middle of the work - particularly since the obligatory ballet has been cut. But those with voices sing handsomely and, happily, in a properly French style. Edgaras Montvidas is a tortured Conrad, and Tassis Christoyannis's dark-voiced Spiridion has sulphur at his heels".


Diapason

2020 octobre

af

af

François Laurent

2020 octobre

"Vurdering: Diapason d'or".


The gramophone

2020 October

af

af

Tim Ashley

2020 October

"Editor's choice: There are some dramaturgical wobbles and the score is uneven, though the best of it is magnificent ... The recording itself is tremendous, conducted with infectious energy by François-Xavier Roth, and with Les Siècles really relishing every shift of colour in Saint-Saëns's gorgeous orchestral palette. Edgaras Montvidas is a fine, empathetic Conrad ... It's immensely enjoyable, and one of Bru Zane's finest achievements to date".