"As both an executive producer and label-head, Love Story signals a failure for Eminem as well, and bears the same structural flaws that nag his own late-career output-namely, a lot of filler, poor sequencing, and just too much of the same damn thing. Em's fingerprints are all over the music and his own production credits yield plodding, heavy-handed beats that don't suit Yelawolf's once-erratic flow ... Yelawolf sounds like he's just going through the motions instead of actually covering ground".