"While Runners lacks Never Hungover Again's consistency and melodic generosity, it likewise functions under the assumption that its new audience might be an anachronism, but it's one worth chasing: people who value the album not so much as a cohesive, continuous 40-minute piece of music but one where every song justifies the act and trust of spending $10 for the whole. With the exception of the brief, fluttering closer "All Things Run", everything could be the "single"-the Sidekicks are beholden to huge choruses with carefully constructed lead-ins, warm harmonies, and quotable lyrics about relatable topics. Remove the crusty production from their past work and nothing here should be a major surprise; it's just more polished in every way, the melodies are less jittery, the dynamics are more pronounced, the presentation is immaculate".