"Rodrigo may not be Handel at his most sublime ... [but] as the recitatives and arias pour out of Handel's cornucopia it bowls along with compelling grace ... Vocally the work is almost all in the top register, with three sopranos, two high countertenors, and one tenor ... But no praise could be too high for the musicianship of this brilliant sextet, or of Cummings's instrumental ensemble: there's ravishing continuo playing and a warm tutti sound".