Musik / cellokoncerter

Cello concerto


Anmeldelser (54)


Klassik heute

d. 5. apr. 2016

af

af

Christoph Schlüren

d. 5. apr. 2016

"Insgesamt gilt hier für Solist und Dirigent, besonders jedoch für den Solisten: die schnellen Tempi sind klarer geformt und auch in ihrem Wiedererkennungswert entschiedener verwirklicht als die langsameren, bei denen zudem, gerade auch bei dem notorisch etwas unruhigen Dausgaard, stets die Tendenz besteht, sie zu zügig zu nehmen".


MusicWeb international

2016 February

af

af

Michael Cookson

2016 February

"There we have it: a Dvořák masterpiece and a Martinů work that deserves greater exposure. Thoroughly engaging".


jcklassisk

d. 7. maj 2014

af

af

John Christiansen

d. 7. maj 2014

"Der musiceres dejligt afrundet uden alt for outrerede dramatiske effekter [Cellokoncert] ... Netop den indre ro er fint til stede i fem mindre stykker, som Weilerstein spiller sammen med pianisten Anna Polonsky".


AllMusic

2014

af

af

James Manheim

2014

"This is a generally satisfying collection of pieces that displays Dvorák's melodic gift, his facility with small pieces that never cloy, and the relationship of these to his larger works, which maintain their popularity because of the way they place lyric episodes into a larger context ...The listener, after an introduction to the great B minor concerto, has other places to go, but this release will satisfy the confirmed Dvorák lover".


Presto classical

d. 31. aug. 2020

af

af

Katherine Cooper

d. 31. aug. 2020

"Editor's choices - August 2020: As well as playing in the West-Eastern Divan Orchestra, the young Iranian cellist performs regularly in recital with Barenboim, and it shows: the Concerto comes across here as chamber music writ large, with some especially delicious, almost improvisatory interplay with the Berlin horn and clarinet (both excellent). Soltani's own arrangements of several Dvořák evergreens for cello ensemble are attractive and unhackneyed, though Stephan Koncz's transcription of the 'New World' Largo takes the palm".


NDR.de

d. 21. aug. 2020

af

af

Marcus Stäbler

d. 21. aug. 2020

"CD der Woche: Der österreichische Cellist Kian Soltani ... ist einer der herausragenden Interpreten seiner Generation. Auf seinem aktuellen Album spielt er Werke von Antonín Dvořák, begleitet von seinem Mentor Daniel Barenboim und der Staatskapelle Berlin ... Kian Soltani spielt ... hinreissend - und verströmt dabei eine Atmosphäre von sanfter Wehmut und Süsse. Man würde sich am liebsten reinlegen in den Klang. Soltani formt auf seinem Stradivari-Cello einen warmen und edlen Ton und dichte Bögen ... Solist und Orchester atmen gemeinsam und tauchen in die romantische Stimmung der Musik ein ... Das Album ist ein Genuss".


Politiken

d. 29. maj 2014

af

af

Thomas Michelsen

d. 29. maj 2014

"Emnet på cellisten Alisa Weilersteins nye album er Dvoraks berømte tjekkiske cellokoncert, og den amerikanske musiker giver den alt, hvad den kan trække ... Med en ekstrem intensitet, der når helt ud i krogene af musikken. Men som også kommer helt op i det røde felt. Med fuldt tryk på følelsesbarometeret ... Hele vejen igennem har hun det ekstra med hensyn til energi, overskud og viljestyrke".


Jyllands-posten

d. 25. apr. 2014

af

af

Jens Povlsen

d. 25. apr. 2014

"Weilerstein gør stadig indtryk, selv om hendes bud hælder til den lidt for lyttevenlige side. Større kontraster ville have klædt Weilerstein, der spiller med stor volumen det meste af tiden. Indimellem lykkes det hende at formulere koncerten som private samtaler mellem den inderlige cellostemme og det store orkester, men helt tæt på kommer man aldrig".


Politiken

d. 12. feb. 2008

af

af

Thomas Stolting

d. 12. feb. 2008

"Har vi virkelig brug for flere indspilninger af Dvoráks cellokoncert? Efter at have hørt Pieter Wispelweys fortolkning, optaget live i 2006, er svaret: Ja! ... Som lytter bliver man holdt i et fast, men kærligt musikalsk greb. For Wispelweys klangbehandling er imponerende, hvad enten der er tale om de aggressive og pågående passager eller om de mere rolige. Og dirigenten Iván Fischer er hele tiden opmærksom på at skabe balance mellem solisten og orkestret".


Berlingske tidende

d. 2. okt. 2007

af

af

Søren H. Schauser

d. 2. okt. 2007

"Wispelwey hører til tidens mest spændende strengespillere, især fordi han spiller alt fra Bach til Britten og gør det lige indforstået ... Ingen kender musikken bedre, heller ikke på den videnskabelige måde. Alligevel kan der være noget tamt, måske endda lidt støvet over hans lyd. Desuden savner man af og til den gode historie".


Politiken

d. 31. jan. 2006

af

af

Michael Bo

d. 31. jan. 2006

"Den 41-årige tyske cellist Jan Vogler er overbevist om, at han i dybderne af Dvoráks cellokoncert kan finde beviset for, at den er en programmusikalsk hengivelse til svigerinden, som han var forelsket i ... Og hvor bliver der dog spillet smukt og vedkommende ... Vogler har en fin syngende melankoli, der klæder Dvorák. Hans spil er slankt, senet og veltalende".


Jyllands-posten

d. 30. okt. 2007

af

af

John Christiansen

d. 30. okt. 2007

"Cellisten Peter Wispelweys og Iván Fischers tolkning ... er glimrende med bevægelighed og autentisk tjekkisk orkesterklang".


Jyllands-posten

d. 13. jan. 2009

af

af

John Christiansen

d. 13. jan. 2009

"Det er en ren fornøjelse at lytte til dette smukke, renfærdige cellospil, som er længere borte fra Dvoraks symfoniske dramaer, end man sædvanligvis hører cellokoncerten. En topindspilning ... Helt igennem en anbefaling værd".


BBC music magazine

2016 June

af

af

Helen Wallace (musikanmelder)

2016 June

"Cellist Christian Poltéra and conductor Thomas Dausgaard give Dvorak's Cello Concerto a lusty warmth and spontaneity ... But what sets this recording apart is this reading of Martinu's Cello Concerto No. 1, a hugely appealing work far too rarely performed ... Poltéra sustains its cantilenas with a glowing intensity that builds towards a monumental and profound cadenza ... This reading stands beside the best".


Diapason

2016 juillet-août

af

af

Nicolas Derny

2016 juillet-août


Fono Forum

2016 Juni

af

af

Thomas Schulz (f. 1960)

2016 Juni

"Wir [vernehmen] ein transparentes, gedankenvolles, gleichwohl durchaus gefühlvolles, aber eben nicht überbordendes Spiel, das dem Konzert ausgezeichnet zu Gesicht steht. Besonders schön gelungen ist der langsame Satz ... Stimmig auch die Werkzusammenstellung, die der Einspielung zusätzliches Repertoirewert verschafft".


Diapason

2014 juin

af

af

Nicolas Derny

2014 juin


BBC music magazine

2014 August

af

af

Jan Smaczny

2014 August

"Vurdering: BBC music concerto choice" - "This new issue has been put together with remarkable care ... But it is the performance of the Concerto that is centre stage and here Alisa Weilerstein is extraordinary ... This is one of the great ensemble performances of this concerto avaiable ... A performance to treasure".


Fono Forum

2014 September

af

af

Andreas Friesenhagen

2014 September

"Vurdering: Empfehlungen des Monats" - "Hier haben aber auch die dramatischeren Passagen jene Geschmeidigkeit und Deutlichkeit der Diktion, die man in pathetischeren Darstellungen vermisst".


BBC music magazine

2007 November

af

af

Jan Smaczny

2007 November

"He (Wispelway) does bring exceptional qualities to bear in a reading that has a profound sense of drama ... If as a whole he does not match Fournier's wonderfully idiomatic vintage performance on DG, this is a modern reading which stands very high in the catalogue. Iván Fischer accompanies with precision and an unfussy approach to the concerto's rhetoric".


The Penguin stereo record guide

1975

af

1975

"The collaboration of Rostropovich and Karajan makes for superb results, warm as well as refined in reflection of the finest qualities in each of the two principals ... There have been few recorded accounts so deeply satisfying. The result is unashamedly romantic, with many moments of dalliance, but the concentration is never in doubt. Superb playing by the Berliners".


The gramophone classical music guide

2009

af

2009

"Vurdering: Gramophone diamond (Simply the best)" - "None to match it for the warmth of lyrical feeling, the sheer strength of personality of the cello playing and the distinction of the partnership between Karajan and Rostropovich. Any moments of romantic licence from the latter, who's obviously deeply in love with the music, are set against Karajan's overall grip on the proceedings. The orchestral playing is superb".


BBC music magazine

2013 November

af

af

Jan Smaczny

2013 November

"Vurdering: BBC music orchestral choice" - "This performance is remarkably fine and the interaction between soloist and orchestra generates one of the most exciting ensemble performances of recent years. Steven Isserlis is inside the piece from the start ... This is a performance to treasure for its beauty and commitment".


Diapason

2015 novembre

af

af

Nicolas Derny

2015 novembre


Fono Forum

2015 September

af

af

Ole Pflüger

2015 September

"Erstaunlich aufgeräumt, fast nüchtern wirkt diese Einspielung. Kein Scheppern des Bogens auf den Saiten. Kein Tippen der Finger auf dem Griffbrett. Präzision statt Exzess. Klingt Langweilig? Ist es aber nicht ... Freunden gestochen scharfer Rhythmen und fein gewobener Harmonien wird sie gefallen".


BBC music magazine

2015 December

af

af

Helen Wallace (musikanmelder)

2015 December

"Moser gives us an exciting, high-tension ride with an impressive sense of structure. He's a musician of alacrity, power and style: virtuosic passages benefit from his fleet effortlessness".


Diapason

2014 septembre

af

af

Nicolas Derny

2014 septembre


Fono Forum

2014 August

af

af

Norbert Hornig

2014 August

"Er legt sich mit Herzblut hinein in den Solopart, gestaltet kantabel, kultiviert, geschmackvoll und behauptet sich sehr achtbar gegenüber der gewichtigen Konkurrenz. Sehr zu begrüssen ist, dass er auch die zauberhaften kleineren Werke mit Orchester aufgenommen hat ... Ein attraktives, sinnvoll geschnürtes 'Dvorák-Paket'".


BBC music magazine

2020 October

af

af

Helen Wallace (musikanmelder)

2020 October

"Concerto choice: He's an exceptionally free, agile and fluent player, and youthful impetuosity powers the first and third movements, only occasionally marred by a rather hectic vibrato. There's a sense of real partnership with the orchestra, a lovely chamber-like dialogue, the rounded woodwind and brass timbres of the Berliners providing an ideal foil for his brightly-lit line. Soltani gives himself over completely to the lavish oratory of the concerto's coda, handled with masterly care by Barenboim".


Diapason

2020 novembre

af

af

Nicolas Derny

2020 novembre


High fidelity (Kbh.)

Årg. 37, nr. 4 (2004)

af

Årg. 37, nr. 4 (2004)


Berlingske tidende

d. 6. jan. 2004

af

d. 6. jan. 2004


Berlingske tidende

d. 15. nov. 2000

af

d. 15. nov. 2000


The gramophone

2016 May

af

af

Hannah Nepil

2016 May

"Christian Poltéra's ... big soloistic statements are strikingly ego-free, and these recordings of Czech concertos make the point ... He gives us seamless, breathless phrases, a clear sense of over-arching structure and plenty of vigour [Dvořák] ... The first movement explodes like a pack of fireworks; the second stands out for its lyrical intensity. It makes for a thrilling performance [Martinů]".


Weekendavisen

d. 17. aug. 2001

af

d. 17. aug. 2001


The gramophone

2014 July

af

af

Andrew Achenbach

2014 July

"For all the redblooded temperament and freewheeling spontaneity on show, though, it's in the concerto's softer, frequently chamber-like passages that Weilerstein and those inimitably songful Czech winds really come into their own ... A disc worthy of the highest plaudits".


The gramophone

2007 Awards

af

af

Edward Greenfield

2007 Awards

"Vurdering: G (Gramophone recommends)" - "This is concert recording at its finest - Wispelway's Dvorák is electrifying".


High fidelity (Kbh.)

Årg. 39, nr. 2 (2006)

af

af

Mogens Wenzel Andreasen

Årg. 39, nr. 2 (2006)

"En af de bedste indspilninger, jeg har hørt af denne koncert, som er et mesterværk på højeste plan, bevægende smuk og fornemt udført ... Dvoráks mørktfarvede, slaviske romantik virker her næsten ophøjet smuk, fuld af lidenskab og spillet med en lige så mørktfarvet, varm cellotone. En cd, som er vanskelig at komme uden om".


The gramophone

2006 March

af

af

Edward Greenfield

2006 March

"The brilliant German cellist Jan Vogler has collaborated with Dvorak scholar Michael Beckerman in devising a sequence which delves beyond Dvorak's masterpiece. A fine, illuminating issue in a crowded field of concerto recordings".


Diapason

2006 janvier

af

af

Pierre-E. Barbier

2006 janvier

"Vurdering: Diapason d'Or" - "Jan Vogler, qui fut le splendide violoncelle solo de la Staatskapelle de Dresde, impose, avec un rare sens de la couleur, un ton épique, un son puissant, absent des gravures récentes au style curieusement da camera".


The gramophone

2013 October

af

af

Andrew Achenbach

2013 October

"Isserlis is on spellbindingly eloquent form in an entrancingly poetic and urgently communicative reading that really does sound like it's being captured on the wing ... Harding and the Mahler CO are with him every step of the way; theirs is a real, breathing collaboration ... Don't miss this special release".


International record review

2013 October

af

af

Raymond S. Tuttle

2013 October

"Given the popularity of the B minor Concerto, it was inevitable that someone would reclaim the earlier effort in A major ... They make a good case for it, with eloquent playing from Isserlis and rich, dark colours and dramatic thrust from both the cellist and the orchestra ... Given the bonus of big, bold and warm sound ... this recording should leave those who acquire it with no regrets".


The gramophone

2015 Awards

af

af

Rob Cowan (f. 1948)

2015 Awards

"Vurdering: G (Editor's choice)" - "This new version is up there with the best of them and could happilty serve as a credible first choice".


International record review

2015 February

af

af

John Warrack

2015 February

"Daniel Müller-Schott's performance is a worthy addition to the company of the distinguished. He has a clear, warm but not overwhelming tone, and the musicianship to work closely with Michael Sanderling and the orchestra ... A fine artist, and this is an attractive assemblage of some of Dvorák's most charming music as well as one of his masterpieces".


The gramophone

2020 October

af

af

Richard Bratby

2020 October

"The slightly old-fashioned word that kept finding its way into my notes was 'nobility' ... Soltani fills gracefully shaped phrases with eloquent, butterscotch-tinted cello sound. He crafts a lucid, clearly defined and distinctly classical reading, not without humour ... Both Barenboim and Soltani husband their reserves of expression, though when they do cut loose they go straight for the heart ... If this is your sort of thing, you won't hear it done better".


The gramophone

2009 April

af

af

Edward Greedfield

2009 April

"Vurdering: Editor's choice" - "An unusual but attractive coupling of two concertos composed in America ... It is Capucon's gift to play with warm intensity while keeping a relatively steasy pulse ... Altogether a version of this much-recorded work [Dvorak] which stands comparison with any in the catalogue".


International record review

2009 February

af

af

John Warrack

2009 February

"It is the Adagio which is most succesful, when his sense of line and his rich tone are heard at their best, and the finale has plenty of life".



Informationer og udgaver