"Athanaël is sung extremely well by baritone Joshua Hopkins ... Andrew Staples is a most accomplished tenor ... Then, Erin Wall as Thaïs is really, really good, and it is only in comparison with the luxuriant voice of Renée Fleming that any criticism can be levelled ... Andre Davis paces the opera perfectly and the orchestra play splendidly. The large chorus also fulfils its rôle to perfection, and all the minor parts are sung very well indeed; there is not a weakness anywhere".
"Opera choice: To Thaīs herself Erin Wall brings a clean, pliant soprano used with discretion and judgement ... Dark of presence, Joshua Hopkins makes a vehement Athanaël ... Davis presents a perceptive account of one of Massenet's best creations, the Canadian orchestra offering fine-textured playing as they respond with assurance to the composer's unerring gift for scene painting ... It surpasses many earlier efforts not only in terms of casting and conducting, but also in taking one of Massenet's finest scores seriously".
Politiken
d. 27. aug. 2000
af
d. 27. aug. 2000
Berlingske tidende
d. 6. sep. 2000
af
d. 6. sep. 2000
Weekendavisen
d. 20. okt. 2000
af
d. 20. okt. 2000
Kristeligt dagblad
d. 28. aug. 2000
af
d. 28. aug. 2000
Operabladet Ascolta
(2000) 19. årgang nr. 4
af
(2000) 19. årgang nr. 4
Jyllands-posten
d. 11. sep. 2000
af
d. 11. sep. 2000
The gramophone
2020 August
af
af
Tim Ashley
2020 August
"[Davis's] understanding of Massenet's often deliberate blurring of the dividing line between sensual and spiritual experience is unquestionably acute. The playing is excellent, with a refined sensuousness of texture throughout ... [Hopkins's] is a remarkable, unforgettable performance, sung with consistently expressive beauty, and quite superbly characterised ... makes the new recording more than well worth hearing".
Klassisk
2020, nr. 58
af
2020, nr. 58
"Sir Andrew Davis ... har gjort Jules Massenets opera 'Thaïs' til en af sine specialiteter ... Operaen er meget mere end den berømte 'meditation' for soloviolin ... På den nye indspilning har Andrew Davis hyret canadiske Erin Wall til at synge rollen [som Thaïs], og ifølge Financial Times er Erin Wall "en drøm af en Thaïs, der præsenterer karakteren med udstråling, uberørt skønhed og toptoner, der kildrer"".