"When things click, as on the album's standout track Tuttifrutti, and the melancholic tang of the band's best songwriting peeks out behind the silly stuff, it works gloriously. But occasionally, as on the gelato-worshipping Fior Di Latte or the sub-Moroder Fleur De Lys, the mix seesaws into preposterousness. Ti Amo is a bold experiment, but Phoenix would be better served by keeping things chilled".