"Foam Island prominently features interviews with people around Huddersfield. Far from exploitation or class tourism, the clips they include are respectful, sometimes heartbreaking and other times hopeful ... Foam Island has some of Darkstar's best songs, and the tones are varied considering the downcast subject matter. "Go Natural," a slice of peppy and orchestral electro-pop, is the odd one out, while the acid-tongued "Pin Secure" recalls slinky, post-millennial R&B in its mechanical herky-jerk".